Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?

I recently watched The Thinning on YouTube, after reading about it here on this site. 🙂 After I couldn’t help but wonder if YouTubers like Logan Paul were the new reality TV stars?

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?


In 1992 MTV aired a TV show called The Real World and almost overnight the cast become stars, the first in a series of reality TV stars. Unlike movie stars, the reality TV stars fame was always short-lived and typically only lasted about 5 minutes after their reality TV show came to an end.

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?

Over the next 26 years, reality TV exploded and we got more reality TV shows than we knew what to do with. A few things happened — as more people were willing to do whatever it took to be on TV, the networks began paying less money.

For example, the stars of ‘Here Comes Honey Boo Boo‘ were rumored to be paid about $40,000 an episode but that money had to be split between the entire cast which includes Honey Boo Boo, her mom, her dad, and her siblings.

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?



Some reality TV stars make as little as $1,500 an episode. If their show is a success and it’s brought back for a second or third season, they might make as much as $7,000 to $10,000 an episode and there are only so many episodes in a season. But getting that pay boost is rare. Reality TV shows don’t tend to have a long shelf life.

But even those reality shows that are renewed for multiple seasons don’t often bring the stars the big bucks. “Pawn Stars,” one of History’s highest-rated shows, paid Richard Harrison $15,000 an episode in 2014. Another star, Chumlee, who is weathering some legal problems now, made $25,000 an episode. But again those big numbers are for a reality TV show that is very popular.

Most reality TV stars don’t make anything close to that, yet people still line up to be in a show, any show they can, even if that means they’ll only make $500 for their appearance.

Some reality TV stars are smarter than others. They cash in on their fame and get themselves cast on another show to extend their 15 minutes of fame. If they can do that enough times, they could get enough fans to get some deals with companies and end up millionaires.

Sure it’s rare but not unheard of. Take Bethenny Frankel who got her start in 2005 as a contestant on the reality game show The Apprentice: Martha Stewart, in which she was the runner-up. Next, she was cast by Bravo on The Real Housewives of New York and starred in 7 of its 10 seasons and then got her own spin-off series,  Bethenny Ever After which lasted 2 seasons, and then she landed her own talk show which lasted only a few months.

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?

After being on The Real Housewives on New York for just one season she started her Skinnygirl brand, which was originally just some cookbooks. In 2011 she created the Skinnygirl cocktail company and would go on to sell that company for an amazing $100 million.

Still, reality TV has been around for 25 years and while there are some success stories like Bethenny Frankel and the Kardashians – there are far more stories of people who had their 15 minutes of fame and moved on. Some worse off than when they started, due to issues with drugs or taxes.

Then came YouTube and the rise of the YouTuber and social media influencers like Pewdiepie, Tati and Jenna Marbles.

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?

YouTube became a place where almost anyone had the chance to have their own platform and make an incredible amount of money doing it.

Logan Paul has 18.5 million subscribers and earns an estimated $100,000 a month in ad revenue. That doesn’t even include what he earns from merchandise sales and other projects like what he was paid to appear in the first three seasons of Threesome and the movie The Thining and the sequel.

Eva Gutowski of ‘lifeaseva‘ has 9.3 million subscribers and makes an estimated $80,000 a month in ad revenue. That’s significantly more than most reality TV stars make a year.

Tati who is a popular beauty guru, talks about makeup in her videos to her 4.8 million subscribers and that generates her almost $100,000 a month.

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?

Pewdiepie 81 million subscribers. He gains an average of about 120,000 new followers every single day. His videos have been watched a total of over 20 billion times. He makes a rumored $500,000 a month.

These are just a few of the popular YouTubers. There are quite a few more.

But are they really the next reality tv stars?

  • Do they have the fame and fans the reality tv stars have? Check.

Someone like YouTuber Shane Dawson has 18.8 million subscribers and gains about 10,000 new subscribers per day. Every day his videos are watched on average 6.7 million times – that’s 7 days a week, 365 days a year.

Reality TV shows don’t have those kinds of numbers. The Bachelor is a very popular reality TV show that when on, about 2 million people tune in to watch. This year The Bachelor had 12 episodes (one a week for 12 weeks). Doing the math that means that a total of 24 million people watched this season of The Bachelor.

Shane Dawson has that many eyeballs on his videos in just two days.

  • Do they make as much money (or more) than reality tv stars? Check.

Top 100 YouTubers easily make way more money in YouTube ad revenue than most reality TV stars get paid per episode. While some reality TV stars like Bethenny Frankel have brand deals but YouTubers by far have more. Without a doubt, YouTubers win in this area.

Even smaller YouTubers can parlay their fame into promoting things like books they can self-publish on Amazon and make a decent amount of money.

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?

So what do you think? Are YouTuber’s the new Reality TV stars? Have YouTuber’s changed the way we look and think of the word “celebrity?”


Be sure and check out “How to be a Social Media Influencer,” which is now available at Amazon!

Be sure and check out "How to be a Social Media Influencer," which is now available at Amazon!

author avatar
Hello! I'm here to bring you all things pop culture. If you want me to research or write about something specific let me know.

Share this:

Are YouTubers the new Reality TV Stars?

Leave a Reply

Girl Power Girl Strong™ is an online community for women. This site offers a wealth of information on contemporary women’s issues, such as help with dating and relationships, career advice, and more. This website encourages and celebrates women’s empowerment, independence, confidence, and strength.

Right now, there are currently 247 others online, just like you!
Get The Latest Updates

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Enter your email address to subscribe to this Girl Power Girl Strong™ newsletter and receive notifications of new posts by email.

No spam, notifications only about new website posts.